The Earwyrms 200, Part III: Country Girls & Power Pop

ISSUE #345

In 2021, I wrestled with the impossible: I isolated the 100 greatest songs ever written.

Five years later, I'm ready to reckon with the terror I hath wrought—it’s time to expand the list from 100 to 200. That’s right: we’re adding a cool hundred to the Earwyrms Canon.

Hear the first 20 additions here and here.


“For Today I Am a Boy” | ANOHNI and the Johnsons
2005

This song was the nearest miss of the original Canon. My only excuse for omission is cowardice. My high school music mentor, gone off to college—an ersatz older brother—played it once over Mizzou radio. I listened on the website’s embedded player. As a boy of certain sensitivities, I used to use the power of the computer room for control, processing emotions as long as possible outside of my lonely bedroom.

The song itself? An eternal gift. A well of strength. Nobody actualizes you except you. We all grow up eventually.

 

“Problem With It” | Plains
2022

The only song on the 200 written after the original Canon was published, “Problem With It” has no problem closing out a long night. It’s perfectly written, perfectly harmonized, perfectly taped—but Phil Cook’s guitar solos and Crutchfield’s low register pump it through your blood. Surrender can be strength. There’s power in leaving when the fight is fruitless.

 

“I'll Fly Away” | Albert E. Brumley
1932

Written in 1929 at the Hartford Music Company—a Southern-gospel music school in western Arkansas—Albert E. Brumley published ”I’ll Fly Away” three years later, and folks quickly spread it around. Light and lilting, it does what spirituals do best by paving way to a better place, promising deliverance from mortal pain. 68 years later, it went octuple-Platinum, thanks to a recording by Gillian Welch and Alison Kraus for O, Brother Were Art Thou?

 

“Prove My Hypotheses” | Death Cab for Cutie
1999

You wouldn’t know it from the emo-twee of their mid-2000s radio hits, but Death Cab for Cutie actually rips harder than a bullet train and was born with one of the greatest rhythm sections to ever come from the United States of America. Like The National, they’ve loaded their catalog with weepies that secretly fuck. Death Cab’s best work, in one word? Propulsive.

This early cut from well before their first album was brought to my attention when I bought the DVD of their road doc, Drive Well, Sleep Carefully. The “Prove My Hypothese” performance is one of my favorites of all time! The way Nick Harmer goes nuts on the bass. The way they end it like their in The Clash and not The Office. Their shirts and those ties. One of the greatest group of musicians of all time.

 

“You Don’t Own Me” | Lesley Gore
1963

A virtuosic piece of music theory—starting in the very antagonistic G Minor, it climbs to the triumph of G Major in the chorus, making it feel how it does when you finally stand up for yourself. But it doesn’t stop there! As things in life absolutely do not. She soars ever forward, onward and upward to A-flat—then to A—then to B-flat! Don’t you tell her what to do.

Identity, the driving force of all defense mechanisms, is better understood here than in any textbook: “Just let me be myself / That’s all I ask of you.”

 

“Nantes” | Beirut
2007

A simple Piaf number with millennial production value, the sophisticated sound of “Nantes” belies the simplicity of its composition. You can play it on solo piano or in a quartet. This is Philip Glass minimalism with a TCM touch.

 

“Detroit Has a Skyline” | Superchunk
1995

Mac McCaughan and Jim Wilbur of Superchunk are constantly overlooked as guitar heroes. One of them is always making the frets talk while the other chugs along—their interplay is more than texture; it’s counterpoint. Out of many examples of their wizardry, “Detroit has a Skyline” stands out with its message in sticking up for yourself.

Even Detroit—that forgotten American metropolis, the once-bustling fifth of nine children—has a skyline, and millions who still call the metro home. It’s a metaphor! We encounter three types of people in our lives: those who never gave a shit; those who did and have moved on; those who have stuck around through thick and thin.

 

“Me and Mia” | Ted Leo and the Pharmacists
2004

Poetry and songwriting are uniquely equipped to coded messaging. If you know, you know; if you crack the code, your mind is open.

Dozens of the most beloved people in my life have struggled with eating disorders. I myself don’t have the healthiest relationship with food. “Me and Mia,”—a non-judgmental, unpatronizing portrait of that particular war with life, living, our culture, the mind—was a profound awakening in my understanding. It deepens every time I listen.

It’s a valiant, beautiful work of connection and communication; a perfect morsel of power pop; a song that does the thing only songs can do—move me when I’m too dense to listen, stick in my head so I get time to understand.

 

“Wide Open Spaces ” | The Chicks
1998

The Chicks don’t get enough love, and this is one of their greatest heartland songs. The way the Easterns and Pacifics see it? Texas is Iowa is Nebraska is Ohio is Kentucky is Arkansas. Anyone from a big enough family, or a small enough town, knows what it feels like to be mistaken, to be replaced by one with bigger britches. We also know responsibility. It’s on us make our own way.

 

“Surrender ” | Cheap Trick
1978

“Surrender” is a masterpiece of musical modulation—mirroring its message of letting go, it rises from B-flat, to B-natural, to universal C. It soars musically, paved the way for The Replacements; yet it’s also of wood-paneled basements, was never in Stranger Things, and remains forever perfect.

All great poetry comes from blending the specific and the universal. The specific? Learning young about Boomer racism, venereal diseases, and the legacy of American imperialism. The universal? The joy of melody. The ecstasy of release. The power of surrender. Learning anything at all, despite our dumb brains.

 

Next week—more to come.


Next
Next

The Earwyrms 200: Part II